Here is my .02
When and where?
Both are awesome setups and one is not better than the other. it the one that is best suited for the driver.
F1 did not go supercharged because everyone is used to driving a turbo.
Why i got SC instead of turbo?
A: When I stomp on it at the line, I want it to take off like a batt outta hell.
I don't have time for spooling. in most cases, your at the next light by the time your turbo is spooled up.
b: I DON'T WANT TO KILL MYSELF! I've driven a grand national. EEEK! When the turbo spools up and goes it kicks you like friggen NOS! now immagine that in a corner.. Yikes!
C: Turbo is much harder in a clutch.. (if you drive it right) you need to keep the turbo spooled and have to ride the clutch between shifts.
D: I hate the sound of a blowoff valve... (that one is just personal, but I can't stand a little neon with a blowoff valve louder then the engine... )
But that is because of my taste and driving style.
Turbo is mean only for smaller displacement engines. (that is why dragsters can't use them..
They deliver good pressure, but not as much MASS of air.
Cheers!
Eric